Video answer · Seal Tech Insulation
Seal it.
The short answer
Seal it. Closed-cell spray foam on the crawl space walls and rim joists, plus a heavy vapor barrier over the ground, turns a damp, open crawl space into a dry, sealed one that pests have a hard time getting into.
A vented crawl space with a dirt floor pulls in humid outside air and moisture from the ground. That moisture can lead to musty smells, mold, wood rot, and cold floors above. Damp, sheltered spaces with gaps are also exactly what mice and insects look for.
Once the crawl space is sealed, it stays drier and the floors above stay warmer. Some homes also need a dehumidifier or conditioned air to manage humidity. Your evaluation will tell you.
Cured spray foam is not a food source and does not give rodents soft nesting material the way fiberglass does. Sealing gaps also removes many of their entry points.
We will inspect it and show you what is going on down there.